Should a master teach an apprentice everything?

AgoraForo - Digital Marketplace & Freelancer Forum

Niyi Briggs

Well Known
Member
Nov 27, 2022
7,825
318
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.100
The master can only give an apprentice what he or she needs to find a footing in the business. The apprentice must develop his own style and identity.
 

IB D

Well Known
Member
Jan 6, 2023
5,443
194
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.101
I trust some masters. They won't say anything to show you how work is done. You have to learn by watching him do it. That is very rampant in barbing salons and make up studios. If you can't grab by watching, you are completely on your own.
 

Etini Willie

Notable
Member
Nov 22, 2022
3,421
93
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.501
As much as possible the master must teach the apprentice all what he knows that has made him a success in the business. Quit that insecurity of an apprentice knowing more than the master. Every master should strive to raise apprentices that area better than them.
 

IB D

Well Known
Member
Jan 6, 2023
5,443
194
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.101
As a master, I would teach my apprentice the inevitable basics that he or she needs. The rest, he has to go figure it himself or herself. That is the one that would stick to him more.
 

Naiwen

Unfamiliar
Member
Jun 18, 2022
133
44
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.000
I don’t think so personally, I think an apprentice should learn in their own and even create their new practices. That way, it shows that they have their own ideas and they should even surpass their master. In whatever trade they might have. So I don’t think personally that a good master is someone whom teaches their apprentice everything.
 

Bisolami

Very Familiar
Member
Sep 19, 2022
17,833
1,538
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.078
As a master, I would teach my apprentice the inevitable basics that he or she needs. The rest, he has to go figure it himself or herself. That is the one that would stick to him more.
But there are some kind of things that you should not teach them and I also believe that you cannot teach them all. This is why self learning is better so that they can develop themselves
 

aovurevu

Somewhat Known
Member
May 4, 2023
756
36
Dex
$0.100
Raw Dex
$0.000
We have situations where people go to understudy other people that have attained a certain level of mastery in a particular field.

They said that masters don't show apprentices everything about what they are learning. Is that true?

Is it right?

Would you show your apprentice all?
I believe they do reserve some knowledge to make themselves feel superior , otherwise they are on the same level as their apprentice, they do this mostly for parts they learn on their own and not necessarily learning from their master too
 

Etini Willie

Notable
Member
Nov 22, 2022
3,421
93
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.501
I use to have apprentices and I know the ones that would gi ahead to do great in the industry from their approach to apprenticeship. I would teach you everything if you can't discover things for yourself but I know you would be limited. A good apprentice should be able to discover new things.
 

cherry123

Popular
Member
Sep 5, 2022
27,449
2,611
Dex
$0.401
Raw Dex
$0.090
it wouldn't be a bad idea to teach an apprentice the basics. But the person can still go a step further to teach other things that will benefit the apprentice
 

Etini Willie

Notable
Member
Nov 22, 2022
3,421
93
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.501
It is mental laziness for an apprentice to sit down and wait for the master to teach him everything in today's world. When learning is everywhere. You just need the foundational knowledge from your Master.
 

cherry123

Popular
Member
Sep 5, 2022
27,449
2,611
Dex
$0.401
Raw Dex
$0.090
Well nothing wrong with learning more from a teacher , mental laziness it not. Though I don't support apprentice sitting down and waiting for the master to teach everything you can be creative too
 

Passiveearner

Notable
Member
Dec 28, 2022
3,318
205
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$6.152
There are many people who now learn many different things through online classes. However, certain skills cannot be taught to a student through this particular method, so it all depends on what kind of skill you want to learn.
 

uptrendfinancialsignal

Well Known
Member
Nov 24, 2022
8,905
181
Dex
$0.004
Raw Dex
$0.121
There are many people who now learn many different things through online classes. However, certain skills cannot be taught to a student through this particular method, so it all depends on what kind of skill you want to learn.
Online is very broad and it has given a lot of people opportunities to make money for themselves by learning different things for free . For instance, you can learn a lot on YouTube for free.
 

Heatman

Team Lead
Member
Jun 14, 2022
5,831
301
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.020
We have situations where people go to understudy other people that have attained a certain level of mastery in a particular field.

They said that masters don't show apprentices everything about what they are learning. Is that true?

Is it right?

Would you show your apprentice all?

Some people will actually tell you that it is right for a master to teach his apprentice everything they need to survive in the new business that they want to go into while others are going to argue that as a master, you should you leave out a few things that is going to protect you from the competition your apprentice is going to bring when he set up his own business.
 

IB D

Well Known
Member
Jan 6, 2023
5,443
194
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.101
My close friend wanted to learn tailoring. She joined an apprenticeship program with an established tailor. And just one year in, she does styles that her madam can't. In apprenticeship, it is all about the basics and few important tips. The rest is all up to the apprentice.
 

Heatman

Team Lead
Member
Jun 14, 2022
5,831
301
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.020
We have situations where people go to understudy other people that have attained a certain level of mastery in a particular field.

They said that masters don't show apprentices everything about what they are learning. Is that true?

Is it right?

Would you show your apprentice all?
A master should be very proud that his apprentice is now in the same level that the master is, so I believe you should teach him everything that he needs to know to grow.
 

Bisolami

Very Familiar
Member
Sep 19, 2022
17,833
1,538
Dex
$0.000
Raw Dex
$0.078
A master should be very proud that his apprentice is now in the same level that the master is, so I believe you should teach him everything that he needs to know to grow.
I believe that an apprentice should always want to learn more and learn alone so that his boss will be very proud of him and will always want to teach him everything that he knows about the business
 
Back
Top